HTML Sonnet #20
4.4
Evaluation
4.4 avg
7.5 physics accuracy
6.5 design quality
4 animation quality
3 slider ux
2 completeness
3.5 overall
Two crowns Same mass, different density Vertical slider Slider works Slider controls crowns Slider direction correct Full slider range Fall animation Water displacement Rising water level Splash effects Physics correct Live mass value Live volume value Live density value Live displaced water Gilded displaces more Heureka animation No external deps Light bg / dark text Self-contained HTML

A well-built general Archimedes simulator with correct physics and live readouts, but it completely misses the brief: no crowns, no two-object comparison, no falling animation, no splash effects, no rising water level, no heureka moment, and uses a horizontal immersion-depth slider rather than the specified vertical crown-position slider.

7,632 output tokens · claude-sonnet-4-6 · end_turn

A well-built general Archimedes simulator with correct physics and live readouts, but it completely misses the brief: no crowns, no two-object comparison, no falling animation, no splash effects, no rising water level, no heureka moment, and uses a horizontal immersion-depth slider rather than the specified vertical crown-position slider.